Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Veg Vs Ultimate Grain Free Puppy Chicken Sweet Potato and Carrot

Here’s a detailed comparison between Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Vegs and Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy to highlight key differences and advantages:

🐾 Ingredients & Composition Comparison

✅ Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Vegs:

  • Main Protein Source:

    • 35% Chicken (26% Dried Chicken, 5% Chicken Fat, min 4% Freshly Prepared Chicken)

  • Carbohydrates:

    • Sweet Potato (26%), Potato, Peas, Beans (8%)

  • Superfoods & Botanicals:

    • Rosemary, Spinach, Pomegranate, Blueberries (1500mg/kg)

  • Functional Additives:

    • FOS (1000mg/kg), Yeasts (1000mg/kg), Seaweed (1000mg/kg)

✅ Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy:

  • Main Protein Source:

    • 60% Chicken, Turkey & Salmon (including 20% Freshly Prepared Chicken, 14% Dried Chicken, 7% Freshly Prepared Turkey, 7% Freshly Prepared Salmon, 7% Dried Turkey, 3% Dried Salmon, and 2% Chicken Stock)

  • Carbohydrates:

    • Sweet Potato (22%), Potato

  • Superfoods & Functional Ingredients:

    • Omega-3 Supplement, Beet Pulp, Carrot, Peas

    • Glucosamine (170 mg/kg), MSM (170 mg/kg), Chondroitin (125 mg/kg), FOS (96 mg/kg), MOS (24 mg/kg), Nucleotides

📊 Nutritional Analysis Comparison

⚡ Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Vegs:

  • Protein: 30%

  • Fat Content: 14%

  • Crude Fibre: 3.5%

  • Crude Ash: 6%

  • Omega 6: 2.0%

  • Omega 3: 1.5%

  • Calories: 380 Kcal/100g

⚡ Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy:

  • Protein: 29%

  • Fat Content: 15%

  • Crude Fibre: 2.5%

  • Crude Ash: 7%

  • Omega 6: 2.6%

  • Omega 3: 1.6%

  • Calories: 384 Kcal/100g

✅ Winner:

  • Higher Protein: Harringtons (30%) slightly higher than Ultimate (29%).

  • Higher Fat Content: Ultimate (15%) offers more energy-dense nutrition, ideal for active puppies.

  • Better Omega-3 to Omega-6 Ratio: Ultimate provides a slightly higher balance of essential fatty acids.

🦴 Joint Care & Functional Benefits

💊 Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Vegs:

  • Contains botanicals and antioxidants from spinach, pomegranate, and blueberries.

  • Includes FOS and yeast for digestive health but lacks joint care ingredients.

💊 Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy:

  • Rich in functional ingredients:

    • Glucosamine, MSM & Chondroitin – Supports joint development and mobility.

    • Omega-3 Supplement – Promotes skin, coat, and cognitive development.

    • Prebiotics (FOS & MOS) – Supports gut health and immunity.

✅ Winner:

  • Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy provides superior joint support and digestive care, making it more suitable for large breed puppies or those needing added functional benefits.

🥣 Feeding Guidelines & Kibble Size

🍽️ Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Vegs:

  • Recommended feeding amounts vary by age and weight.

  • Kibble size not specified, but likely standard puppy-sized kibble.

🍽️ Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy:

  • Optimal 8mm (+/-1mm) kibble size for puppies.

  • Clear feeding guidelines for different age groups and expected adult weight.

✅ Winner:

  • Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy offers a more detailed and customisable feeding guide, ensuring portion control based on breed size and growth stages.

🧪 Vitamins & Minerals Comparison

🥼 Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Vegs:

  • Vitamin A: 16,000 IU

  • Vitamin D3: 1600 IU

  • Vitamin E: 150 mg

  • Trace Elements:

    • Zinc: 75 mg

    • Iron: 50 mg

    • Manganese: 50 mg

    • Copper: 5 mg

    • Iodine: 1 mg

    • Selenium: 0.2 mg

🥼 Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy:

  • Vitamin A: 15,000 IU

  • Vitamin D3: 2,000 IU

  • Vitamin E: 95 IU

  • Trace Elements:

    • Zinc: 50 mg

    • Iron: 50 mg

    • Manganese: 35 mg

    • Copper: 15 mg

    • Iodine: 1 mg

    • Selenium: 0.3 mg

✅ Winner:

  • Harringtons has slightly higher vitamins and trace minerals, while Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy offers a higher dose of Vitamin D3 and Copper which are essential for immune and bone health.

⚖️ Summary & Recommendation

🥇 Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy – Best for:

  • Puppies requiring joint care and mobility support.

  • Owners looking for a grain-free option with multiple protein sources (chicken, turkey, salmon).

  • Puppies prone to digestive sensitivities with added prebiotics and omega-3.

🥈 Harringtons Superfood Puppy Chicken with Vegs – Best for:

  • Puppies needing high-protein nutrition with natural botanicals.

  • Owners looking for a more affordable option without joint care.

  • Puppies without sensitivity to grains or specific dietary needs.

✅ Final Verdict:
For overall nutrition, joint support, and digestive care, Ultimate Grain-Free Puppy provides a more comprehensive formula for growing puppies.

BUY ULTIMATE PET FOODS - GRAIN FREE PUPPY FOOD